Presley married Rhoda Ellen Smith on 27 Aug 1865 in Shelby County, Indiana, United States. Rhoda (daughter of Carey Smith and Catharine Van Doren) was born in 1846 in Ohio, United States; died before 1900. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

1. Sarah J. Payton was born in 1866 in Illinois, United States; and died.
2. Valentine C. Payton was born in 1868 in Indiana, United States; and died.
3. Jasper N. Payton was born in Feb 1870 in Indiana, United States; and died.
4. John F. Payton was born in 1872 in Kansas, United States; and died.
5. Amanda C. Payton was born in 1874 in Kansas, United States; and died.
6. Mary E. Payton was born in 1877 in Nebraska, United States; and died.
7. Francis M. Payton was born in Feb 1879 in Indiana, United States; and died.
8. Arminta Payton was born in Jan 1881 in Nebraska, United States; and died.
9. Thomas Wiley Payton was born in Jun 1884 in Nebraska, United States; and died.