Phebe married Harlen Kelsay on 5 Sep 1867 in Shelby County, Indiana, United States. Harlen (son of Daniel Kelsay and Margaret Hupp) was born on 19 Jan 1845 in Warren County, Ohio, United States; died on 27 Apr 1920 in Laporte, La Porte, Indiana, United States; was buried on 29 Apr 1920 in Amboy, Miami, Indiana, United States. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

1. Charles W. Kelsay was born on 4 Jun 1868 in Shelby County, Indiana, United States; died on 23 Oct 1948 in Blackford County, Indiana, United States; was buried on 26 Oct 1948 in IOOF Cemetery, Hartford City, Blackford, Indiana, United States.
2. Julia A Kelsay was born in 1869 in Indiana, United States; died on 26 Feb 1946 in Near Hartford City, Blackford, Indiana, United States; was buried in IOOF Cemetery, Hartford City, Blackford, Indiana, United States.
3. Jesse Kelsay was born in 1874 in Tipton County, Indiana, United States; died on 18 Sep 1883 in Tipton County, Indiana, United States; was buried in Albright Cemetery, Kokomo, Howard, Indiana, United States.
4. William Kelsay was born about 1875 in Tipton County, Indiana, United States; died in Tipton County, Indiana, United States.
5. George W Kelsay was born in 1875 in Liberty Township, Tipton, Indiana, United States; died on 7 Feb 1899 in Liberty Township, Tipton, Indiana, United States; was buried in Albright Cemetery, Kokomo, Howard, Indiana, United States.

Jesse married Elizabeth Goodpasture in 1815. Elizabeth died between 1843 and 1850 in Warren County, Ohio, United States. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]