Elijah married Catherine Garver on 19 Jan 1851 in Champaign County, Ohio, United States. Catherine (daughter of Living) was born in 1835 in Ohio, United States; and died. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

1. John W LeMay was born in 1852 in Ohio, United States; and died.
2. David LeMay was born in 1854 in Ohio, United States; and died.
3. Sarah E LeMay was born in 1856 in Ohio, United States; and died.
4. James H LeMay was born in 1859 in Ohio, United States; and died.
5. Mary A LeMay was born in 1864 in Ohio, United States; and died.
6. Ida B. LeMay was born on 27 Oct 1866 in Allen County, Indiana, United States; died on 30 Jan 1924 in Fort Wayne, Allen, Indiana, United States; was buried on 2 Feb 1924 in Bowers Chapel Cemetery, Fort Wayne, Allen, Indiana, United States.
7. Rosadell LeMay was born in 1869 in Indiana, United States; and died.
8. Albert G LeMay was born in 1876 in Indiana, United States; and died.
9. Harry C LeMay was born in 1879 in Indiana, United States; and died.