Sarah married David Potter Kelsay on 5 Sep 1850 in Bridgeton, Cumberland, New Jersey, United States. David (son of Daniel Kelsay and Hannah B Sheppard) was born on 1 Apr 1819 in Greenwich Township, Cumberland, New Jersey, United States; died on 24 Jan 1894 in Vernon County, Missouri, United States; was buried in Old Turner Cemetery, Vernon County, Missouri, United States. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

1. Living
2. William Brown Kelsay was born on 3 Aug 1851 in Cumberland County, New Jersey, United States; died between Jan 1894 and Mar 1897 in Polk County, Arkansas, United States; was buried in Polk County, Arkansas, United States.
3. Sarah Sheppard Kelsay was born on 1 Mar 1853 in Cumberland County, New Jersey, United States; died in 1856 in Cumberland County, New Jersey, United States; was buried in Roadstown Baptist Church Cemetery, Roadstown, Cumberland, New Jersey, United States.
4. Ruth Brown Kelsay was born on 17 Jan 1855 in Cumberland County, New Jersey, United States; and died.
5. Henry Sheppard Kelsay was born on 28 Aug 1858 in Cumberland County, New Jersey, United States; died on 8 Feb 1943 in Near Dederick, Vernon, Missouri, United States; was buried in Mount Pleasant Cemetery, Near Dederick, Vernon, Missouri, United States.
6. Anna Marie Kelsay was born on 30 Dec 1861 in Cumberland County, New Jersey, United States; died after 1943.
7. Harriet Matilda Kelsay was born on 6 May 1863 in Cumberland County, New Jersey, United States; died on 19 Sep 1878 in Near Dederick, Vernon, Missouri, United States; was buried in Old Turner Cemetery, Vernon County, Missouri, United States.
8. May Kelsay was born on 24 Nov 1865 in Cumberland County, New Jersey, United States; died on 6 Jan 1866 in Cumberland County, New Jersey, United States.
9. Hannah Francis Kelsay was born on 24 Feb 1867 in Cumberland County, New Jersey, United States; died on 9 Apr 1941 in Los Angeles County, California, United States.
10. Lelia Katherine Kelsay was born on 8 Oct 1870 in Vernon County, Missouri, United States; died on 29 Jul 1909; was buried in Old Turner Cemetery, Vernon County, Missouri, United States.
11. Nellie Harding Kelsay was born on 18 Sep 1874 in Vernon County, Missouri, United States; died on 26 Sep 1875 in Vernon County, Missouri, United States; was buried in Old Turner Cemetery, Vernon County, Missouri, United States.